Sex work and the law in India: An AIDS INDIA e FORUM debate

05/04/2009 at 09:31 1 comment

A recent discussion about sex work from the AIDS INDIA e FORUM provides an insight into how the laws to control and regulate sex work in India are viewed by various stakeholders.

The AIDS INDIA e FORUM is a virtual organization responding to the HIV and AIDS crisis in India, by connecting the key stake holders together. This FORUM facilitates networking, communication and collaboration among those who are involved or interested in HIV and AIDS related issues in India. One of its main functions is a moderated email list through which members share information and mobilise around issues of common interest.  

The discussion was prompted by the defeat of a new law to regulate sex work – the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Amendment Bill. According to Tripti Tandon of the Lawyers Collective HIV/AIDS Unit the Bill:  

‘Intended to shift legislative policy on sex work from tolerance to prohibition. This was sought to be done through the introduction of a new offence of visiting a brothel, which would penalise clients. It also sought to broaden the meaning of prostitution to include all transactional sex, as opposed to acts involving exploitation on a commercial scale.

By inserting a definition of trafficking for prostitution, the bill attempted to criminalise poverty induced sex work. Other changes included lowering rank of Police authorized to arrest, search and raid brothels and extending detention of sex workers to seven years. Sex workers vehemently opposed these measures which, they believed, would offset any positive effect of decriminalizing soliciting.’

In response to Ms Tandon’s update Dr Krishnan posted a message which questioned the agency of women in the sex industry and pointed to the importance of anti trafficking initiatives. Dr Krishnan’s message implied that sex workers rights advocates are, at best, ignorant and out of touch with the realities or women in the sex industry and, at worst, ‘support the perpetrators to legitimise this human rights violation’.

Dr Jayasree responded to this message arguing that nobody wants to legitimise trafficking, violence and coercion. Dr Jayasree believes that the main purpose of the Bill is to control female sexuality, ‘It is an ideological problem. People engage in sexual activities with or without money transaction. Sometimes, women may have to negotiate for money in their relationships for many reasons. The dominant ideology considers money transaction in sex as something bad. ITPA is drafted on the basis of this ideology…The spirit is to curb all sexual activities outside marriage.’

Meena Seshu made an intervention pointing out that, ‘Even if one woman is there due to force, deception or debt bondage – for me that is a problem. That is the reason why we are arguing for sex work to be declared as work such that we can eliminate or work towards the elimination of ‘force, deception or debt bondage’…The problem is that those that were willing are being unnecessarily penalized because of the perception that ‘majority who opted for this simply did so because there was no option’. Again I would argue that even if one person wanted to do sex work we should have a fair system that allows for just that.’

The exchanges are freely available online and well worth reading in full as they provide an interesting insight into some of the most important debates on sex work in India at the current time. If you are interested in becoming a member of the AIDS INDIA list see their page on yahoo groups.


Entry filed under: gender and sexuality, health, HIV and AIDS, human rights and law. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , .

Lies, damn lies and statistics Conceptual Approaches to Human Trafficking

1 Comment Add your own

  • 1. KexHeddernRew  |  24/09/2011 at 22:31

    Man .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I will bookmark your site and take the feeds additionallyI’m satisfied to find a lot of useful information right here within the submit, we want develop extra strategies in this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Tweet! Tweet! What are we up to?

RSS New on the PLRI website

  • Working Misunderstandings:Donors, Brokers and Villagers in Africa’s AIDS Industry
    off Why do development projects, and AIDS projects in particular, take the forms they do? In this essay we argue that it is because the conflicting interests and world views of the key actors involved—donors, brokers, and villagers—leave only a narrow range of themes and practices that can “work” on the ground. Year of publication:  2014 Theme:  Economics an […]
  • Proposal to European Parliament recommending the Swedish Model
    feature Mary Honeyball, Labour's Spokesperson on the European Parliament's Women's Rights and Gender Equality Committee, has been a vocal supporter of anti-sex work legislation and has written a report to the European Parliament recommending the Swedish Model, which criminalises the purchase of sex. In a blog leading up to the discussion Alex […]
  • Sex Work and Human Rights
    off A useful outline of sex workers rights including the right to health Year of publication:  2013 Theme:  Human Rights and Law Sex Workers And Human Rights.pdf Author:  Urban Justice Centre […]
  • Closing the bridge: Avahan's HIV prevention programs with clients of female sex workers in India.
    off This publication describes Avahan’s HIV prevention interventions with male clients of female sex workers, who are the primary bridge population in India. Year of publication:  2014 Theme:  Health and HIV closing-the-bridge.pdf Author:  The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation Relevant URL: r […]
  • Vulnerability to HIV infection among female drug users in Kathmandu Valley, Nepal: a cross-sectional study
    off Women who use drugs are extremely vulnerable to HIV and sexually transmitted infections (STIs), but studies on risk behaviours and HIV infection among female drug users are limited in Nepal. Year of publication:  2014 Theme:  Health and HIV Author:  Bhagabati Ghimire Relevant URL: read more […]